US importers sued for 'greenwashing' Mexican avocados
83 comments
·July 16, 2025daedrdev
krapp
And as a reminder the Cartels are funded by the CIA.
ASalazarMX
Political groups are the cartels, what we know as cartels are their customer service employees.
The biggest proof is the consistent unwillingness of governments to stop them in any effective way, and I'm not talking about drugs only.
lazide
Sure, but at this point apparently so is everyone?
Are you going to eat or not?
daedrdev
I don't eat Mexican avocados, I buy the more expensive ones grown in the US because of the cartels.
gameman144
I don't think US American avocado farmers are committing war crimes.
lazide
Illegal labor? And if you listen to the current administrations apparent stances on it, give it a year for the war crimes part.
ASalazarMX
"I'm not a bad person, I just indirectly finance brutal cartels".
consumer451
Question for those currently living in the USA. How much do you pay for Hass avocados?
At Lidl in Poland, 2x (perfectly ripe, in a box) Hass can be currently purchased for ~$2.50. This blew my mind when I first saw it, coming from Seattle a few years ago. I believe they are all grown in the EU, in Spain.
Cerium
In the California Bay Area, We don't have avocados in a box, nor perfectly ripe. They are usually in a pile and quite un-ripe (which helps reduce denting in the pile). Depending on size, quality, and organic status they range from about ~1 to ~2.50 each.
You can also buy a full flat of medium size avocados at a Costco Business center for $26 for 35 avocados. They are "stage 2" ripened, which means they will be usable in about 1-2 days on the counter. I buy one and then put them carefully in the fridge and take out about 3-4 at a time. This way I can have fresh ripe avocados for about a month.
hn_throwaway_99
This joke I saw on Reddit about avocado ripeness says it all IMO:
avocado: not ripe
avocado: not ripe
avocado: not ripe
avocado: I'M RIPE NOW
avocado: OK you were in the bathroom so I rotted
lotsofpulp
I cannot relate to this. I buy a bag of unripe (hard) avocados every 3 days or so from Costco, and they take about 2 to 5 days to ripen on the countertop, and then I put them in the fridge and they are good for another 5 days.
SirFatty
"In the California Bay Area, We don't have avocados in a box, nor perfectly ripe. They are usually in a pile and quite un-ripe (which helps reduce denting in the pile). Depending on size, quality, and organic status they range from about ~1 to ~2.50 each."
Same in the Chicagoland area.
meroes
Driving through the Central Valley I’ve seen signs for 10 for $1. No idea if they are extra small, but typically it’s $1-$2.50 per
_alternator_
These are small. But delicious.
paxys
There's a very wide range (depending on location, season, size, quality), but in NYC I expect to pay about $1 to $1.50 an avocado.
consumer451
OK, that is much less expensive than I expected.
Oh, and I should have been more clear. These are "perfectly ripe, in a box" fancy style. Edited gp.
margalabargala
Price primarily varies based on size. Small avocados sell for $0.99 with regularity, while extra large ones may be $2.50 each.
sandworm101
NY is famous for cheap fruit at the street level. That's the advantage of being a port city. Go somewhere like small town Iowa if you are looking for high-priced avocados.
arrosenberg
$1-1.50 at the grocery in SoCal, ripeness may vary. If you go to the farmers market in the summer you can get much better cultivars around 3 for $5. Hass are ok, but Fuerte, Bacon and Reed are easily available and mich tastier.
ryao
I paid $0.65 each last week at Aldi in NY.
giantg2
About $.85 on the east coast. Not perfectly ripe and tend to loose 10-20% to damage.
Izikiel43
> Seattle
4 for 5$ at costco, if I remember correctly.
consumer451
I wasn't a Costco shopper. More of a QFC dude. But are those fancy "perfect" Hass?
If so, I wonder if I created a false memory based on the whole "skip avocado toast" meme, or something.
toast0
Skipping avocado toast isn't about not buying avocados and bread and making a delicious snack for ~ $1 or $2. It's about not paying $12[1] to have once slice of bread and two or three slices of avocado at a restaurant.
[1] Prices have probably gone up, maybe avocado toast at a restaurant is $20 now?
BobaFloutist
There have been on-and-shortages, due to complex supply chains and varying crops.
But the avocado toast was more about overpaying for well-preserved food in trendy cafes. In America, you're almost always paying way more for labor and overhead than for supplies.
lotsofpulp
Yes, they are Hass. Usually bigger than the ones at Aldi or equivalent cheaper store. Obviously not Avozilla size or anywhere near it (unfortunately).
lotsofpulp
Avocados have long been sold in bags of quantity 5 at Costco, and prices have been at least $9 per bag in WA state, if not $10 and $11 for the past year or two.
Used to be $6 or $7 for 5 avocados around 2020. You can see in store prices in the Costco app now. Currently, the Kirkland, WA Costco says $9 for 5 avocados.
Izikiel43
I stand corrected then, might have mixed them with the small ones from trader joes
taude
Something like only 6% of imported produce is inspected (although I've read that 98% isn't).
I've been back-chair commenting for years: wait until all the Whole Foods shoppers find out their favorite South American-Foo actually isn't organic. This seems like a variation on this.
mvdtnz
New Zealand grows avocados sustainably and ethically and exports to USA. If you're interested in buying ethical fruit.
ToucanLoucan
> “Regulatory oversight and validation of good practices are very difficult to document for compliance over the border,” he noted, “They are of course done much better here. And there are validated and official fair market agreements between wholesalers and retailers that require documentation and compliance.”
This is such a bullshit excuse (on the industry's part, to be clear, not the person speaking). If we cared to validate supply chains, it would be done, for this and everything else. We don't because the people in power do not want to know. They don't want to know how greenwashed avocados are, they don't want to know how many diamonds come from conflict zones, they don't want to know how much of their lithium was mined by kids, and all the rest.
We know how to solve these problems and we're choosing not to, and not only are we maintaining harms done overseas in the process, we're also destroying the ability for domestic producers of... everything, really, to compete in the market too.
But the lines gotta go up, so on we go.
nickff
You seem to have a very cynical view, but I think the reason nobody is verifying these things is that they're hard to actually check, and nobody wants to pay for the cost of verification. My only experience with this sort of tracking is compliance with "Conflict Minerals" reporting, and from that I can tell you that tracking and verifying the origin of any commodity or bulk good is nearly impossible to accomplish reliably. There is no real way to know where a refined metal came from, other than accepting a supplier's assurance, and maybe looking through some documents, looking for obvious mistakes. I have to imagine that avocados are similar.
Tadpole9181
I'm so tired of this.
Here, watch this: I'm the US government with the most powerful military and surveillance network on the planet with multiple deployed floating cities. You give me a list of every supplier you use and I will recursively go down that list and every employee they have and if you use slaves to harvest materials at any point, I shut down your entire business and burn every shippng crate of stock until you get a supplier that doesn't use slaves. If you lie, I ship the executives to one of numerous black sites under my control. If we're going to do it to innocent people, shipping them to God knows what death camp without due process, I'm not going to sit here and listen anymore about this "we can't do that" nonsense about our supply chain.
Woah, crazy, slavery solved.
At least have the balls to tell me you want cheap avocados and don't care if child slaves pick them. I'm so God damn tired of all the excuses and smoke and mirrors.
nickff
Let’s say you buy electrolytic capacitors, and you’re worried that they might have conflict tantalum in them. You call up the manufacturer (likely Samsung), and they tell you that they are unable to verify the origin of the metal. Even if they did tell you who sold them the metal, that’s just a refiner, and there is no way to verify whatever they tell you about the origin. Many conflict metals are laundered through other countries, and I am not sure how you’d detect that.
I understand your frustration, but how do you actually verify the origins of these commodities? The professional auditors just blindly trust documentation as far as I can tell.
ToucanLoucan
Cosigned 100%.
The only thing I would say is don't burn the shipping crates. That's just wasteful. Sell the products at 50% off retail to everyone in the US below the poverty line first, then everyone else, and use the funds to pay to improve the working conditions overseas. Our atmosphere doesn't need more waste in it.
ToucanLoucan
> My only experience with this sort of tracking is compliance with "Conflict Minerals" reporting, and from that I can tell you that tracking and verifying the origin of any commodity or bulk good is nearly impossible to accomplish reliably.
This is a better written and more eloquent version of the same excuse I was ranting about in my comment. And I'm afraid my response is not as eloquent:
Bull. Shit.
This is an eminently solvable issue. Make the executives of whatever corporation personally, criminally responsible for the slavery found in their supply chain, and then: Watch the problem be solved. No, I don't know the specifics of how you do it. That's not my job. But we put men on the moon, for Christ's sake. We, creatures not gifted by nature with wings, have the ability to fly at (mostly) reasonable cost, to such a degree where the inconveniences involved in it make it boring to discuss. Everyone in the west moves around in metal boxes with smaller metal boxes within them in which we blow up fuel and air in precise mixes to travel upwards of 80 mph, largely safely. You're telling me the collected knowledge of our species cannot be leveraged to make sure that little kids aren't doing resource extraction!?
> and nobody wants to pay for the cost of verification.
THAT is the real problem, and that's also solvable by the above. I bet the executives at these companies will open the business's purse REAL FAST when it's their, actual physical ass on the line, and not just a paltry fine and firm finger-wagging from the Government.
In reply to the comment below:
> But how do you actually verify the source? Let’s assume that some amount of conflict metals are laundered through other countries, and commingled with ‘clean’ material (which is usually how it happens); how do you figure out whether your supplier is using this material? Do you just trust any documentation they provide? If not, what is it that you’d do?
I mean this is actually one application of crypto that I didn't think was brain-dead stupid. I read a paper about the potential of using blockchains to verify the integrity of materials in supply chains.
More to the point though: I said, I don't know how it's done. But I guaran-damn-tee you that if the corpos will be charged, legally, personally, for the finding of slavery in supply chains, that they will figure it out and fucking quick.
And, even moreso, once you raise the consequences of those "lapses" in ethics to such a degree, it's highly probable that the dubious sources will either improve or shut down entirely, because there will be no corporation in the West ready to do business with them anymore. The risk is simply too high for those in charge of said corporations. They will pay whatever it costs to have materials that are from properly vetted sources.
And of course, I'm not a child, there will still be issues, none of this is a silver bullet for any of it, and there will always be bad actors acting badly. However we still have murders, and we don't just... fine murderers $500 and tell them they better not do it again, despite the fact that we can't catch them all. We catch them and we punish them.
nickff
But how do you actually verify the source? Let’s assume that some amount of conflict metals are laundered through other countries, and commingled with ‘clean’ material (which is usually how it happens); how do you figure out whether your supplier is using this material? Do you just trust any documentation they provide? If not, what is it that you’d do?
Tadpole9181
> No, I don't know the specifics of how you do it.
HN had four stories of the US government violating the 4th and 5th amendments for surveillance for CBP and ICE yesterday alone. The President jokes about revoking citizenship, of both natural born and otherwise. We have had dozens of citizens sent to black sites without due process. We are monitoring social media for immigrants while deporting people to illegal death camp prisons in countries they have never been.
The sitting US president is a convicted rapist who attempted to violently overthrow the government 5 years ago. Who is now covering for the leader of the largest, highest-profile child rape program in history - led by one of his best friends! They, this week, published fabricated videos from official government sources. And the SCOTUS has declared him effectively immune from prosecution.
We are so far from pretending to be a country of rules and laws anymore. So, fuck it, just decree it and call them terrorists at this point. Ship the execs to Guantanamo.
elpakal
The coffee supply chain is one exception imho. There's a market for value-add in the supply chain, I've been amazed to watch the price of specialty coffee keep rising at my favorite roaster.
SoftTalker
I mean, if it bothers you, stop buying avocados. I think the truth is that consumers don't want to know either.
giantg2
Many consumers don't have the time or luxury to know. We're in the "give them bread" phase. We already heavily subsidize many parts of the food chain to keep people happy. Nobody wants to do anything politically that might cause food prices to go up.
lazide
That counts as ‘consumers don’t want to know’, considering how obviously grocery stores prices were an issue in the last election.
BobaFloutist
Oh, ok. Remind me, what food staples are ethical and healthy?
ToucanLoucan
That's not a solution, it's defeatist horseshit. I want avocados. I don't want avocado growers to be able to hide their environmental impact. I want lithium batteries. I don't want kids mining lithium. I want animal products. I don't want animals needlessly tortured in factory farms.
I don't feel like I'm asking for the fucking moon here.
chickensong
Amen. Sadly, it seems next to impossible to bring this sort of change and accountability to industry. In the meantime, our only option is pay premiums (both financially and in effort), which the masses are unable or unwilling to do, in order to opt out of the current system (if it's even possible).
At least you're thinking about the issues, and seem to care, so thanks for that.
ipaddr
But you also want to pay what you have always paid
EA-3167
It's a classic case of revealed vs declared preferences. People overwhelmingly say they want everything ethically sourced, but they reveal that they don't want to pay more for it, which makes ethically sourced anything a luxury good in the cases where it succeeds at all. People want kids out of
At some point IMO people need to grow up and recognize that there's a GULF between the world people say they want, and the one they insist on creating. Assuming that your money follows your stated intentions, you're part of a small minority that truly cares about this to the extent that they're willing to pay for it.
cindyllm
[dead]
gedy
I mean we used to have a strong Avocado industry here in the states before NAFTA. Which reminds me I have to go cut one of the dead Avocado trees in my back from those days.
tomjakubowski
The US avocado industry is still pretty strong compared to pre-NAFTA. See Figure 4. It looks like domestic production (in lbs. of avocados) actually peaked in 2005/2006, and nearly reached that level again in 2010/2011.
huevosabio
The US loooooves to find excuses to block foreign produce.
When it comes to produce, it routinely finds itself on the protectionist side.
As a reminder the Cartels are heavily involved in Mexican avocado production, and regularly commit what would be considered war crimes or crimes against humanity for a nation in their power struggles.