Edgar Allan Poe's life was a mess. But his work was in his command
69 comments
·March 14, 2025robin_reala
the_florist
Many thanks to each of you editors for the sterling work!
I was recently inspired to embark on a project to mirror the Standard Ebooks library, starting with a book that you produced, which happens to be my favorite:
https://flowery.app/books/edgar-allan-poe/short-fiction
Once the business achieves ramen profitability, the next milestone will be to give back with a corporate sponsorship.
robin_reala
Looks good! One minor point: it looks like some of your conversion isn’t keeping accurate styling. For example, if you look at the letter in https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/edgar-allan-poe/short-fict... that starts with “In conformity with an order” you’ll see (in Firefox and Chrome, Safari’s in the process of adding the styling) that the address is 90º as per the original scans. The same in https://flowery.app/books/edgar-allan-poe/short-fiction/thou... falls back to normal display, which is fine but perhaps a little bit of a shame.
the_florist
Good catch! I am still fleshing out the EPUB parser, so loading of CSS and images (other than the SE logo) is not yet supported. I hard-coded the styling for now, which works well enough thanks to the books’ consistent markup.
I also overlooked the diary styling of “Mellonta Tauta.”
spike021
thanks for your work! i was just thinking the other day it had been a while (since university days) since i read his work and i happen to be taking a long-haul flight this week, so need something to read.
glimshe
Very cool. Are the cover images made with AI or classic paintings?
robin_reala
Classic paintings: everything used on Standard Ebooks productions is old enough to be in the US public domain. The artists are in the colophons if you want to find out more.
defrost
Nice work, thanks to you and your fellow editors.
Is there a back story to the Gormenghast collection not being available: https://standardebooks.org/collections/gormenghast
The comment given was:
This book was published in 1946, and will therefore enter the U.S. public domain in 17 years on January 1, 2042.
however it seemed odd that apparently the work was done to prep it and notice appears elsewhere * that material offered is in the public domain .. and then this.No great drama, it just caught my attention, I like the series and wanted to check the art and the copy against what I have here in book form.
* https://standardebooks.org/about/standard-ebooks-and-the-pub...
card_zero
Odilon Redon, Melancholy, and Robert Delaunay, Saint-Séverin No. 3.
https://www.artic.edu/collection?q=Redon - I see he also made a series of prints, "To Edgar Poe"!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Delaunay
...and some seascape with a ship in it, wasn't fussed about that one.
janetmissed
tysm for contributing to standard ebooks, one of my favorite things on the whole internet
timonofathens
If you prefer a physical book, I can recommend: http://www.everymanslibrary.co.uk/classics-author.aspx?lette...
(Not affiliated, I just really like Everyman's Library)
porkbrain
He was also into cryptography: https://www.cs.trincoll.edu/~crypto/historical/poe.html
fixprix
He also had a theory pretty close to the big bang in Eureka. It offended a lot of people at the time
light_triad
Here’s a great reading of The Masque of the Red Death:
https://youtu.be/FskFXD-SQpI?si=UYapck6_51LcAi9y
The Simpsons did a famous rendition of The Raven read by James Earl Jones:
codr7
Alternatively, his life was exactly what it had to be for him to do what he was supposed to.
Mistletoe
I wonder what he would choose if he knew? A comfortable long life and happiness or to be remembered forever?
doctorhandshake
I don’t remember where I read it but I heard David Lynch recounting a conversation with his doctor in which he asked if being prescribed antidepressants could interfere with his creativity. The doctor said he couldn’t rule it out, so Lynch decided he’d rather deal with the symptoms of depression.
Trasmatta
On the other hand, Lynch also went on record saying that an artist doesn't need to suffer to produce great art. And that depression is the enemy of creativity.
IncreasePosts
I chatted with Christopher hitchens about a month before he was diagnosed with the cancer that took him out, and he was adamant that cigarettes and whisky were vital to his writing process. He said he could consider cutting out liquor, but the cigarettes had to stay if he was going to be productive at all.
Mistletoe
I just rewatched David Lynch: The Art Life last night on Max. It's so freaking good. If anyone reading this hasn't seen it, I really recommend it.
rendall
> Lynch decided he’d rather deal with the symptoms of depression
... through meditation.
triceratops
He may not actually be remembered forever. It hasn't even been 150 years since he died.
EDIT: He died in 1849 so it hasn't even been 200 years.
echelon
"long life" is geologically just wishful thinking. We all have the same quality of life outcome when compared against the vastness of time.
What is a billionaire's lavish life to the toil of an artist, inventor, or revolutionary? We all wind up rotting in the blink of an eye. Luxury, pleasure, and dopamine are as fleeting as youth.
It's better to do something of note.
card_zero
If you lived twice as long, you could do two things of note. Twice as better.
BrandoElFollito
"long life" is quantically super dope. You get to live 10^8 times longer than a meson so you have ample time to profit feom luxury, pleasure and dopamine.
And you have time to avoid philosophical discussions that distract you from the above.
jama211
This sounds like some serious copium, we don’t live in the vastness of time, we live now. Not to mention that I can assure you in the vastness of time his work will also be forgotten in an almost as small a “blink of the eye” in geological time.
You could just as easily say “we’ll all end up rotting in the blink of an eye, so better to be happy and enjoy it than waste your time trying pointlessly to do something of note that will be forgotten”.
sometimes_all
I was introduced to Poe via "The Cask of Amontillado". After that, I binge-watched The Fall of the House of Usher when it released, which is a mash-up of a lot of Poe's stories (the show didn't have the subtlety of the original work, but was a lot of fun). Now I'm reading all his short stories.
His work is really cool, and I wish I read him earlier.
Loughla
The cask was my introduction to him as well. Then straight into Arthur Gordon Pym. It is still my favorite book, forever.
ndsipa_pomu
Although Edgar Allan Poe is well known, I think his influence is under appreciated. He pretty much invented the detective story genre with "The Murders in the Rue Morgue" and his "Eureka: A Prose Poem" was early sci-fi that more or less invented the idea of the Big Bang.
DevDesmond
There is a Sci-Fi Noir TV show "Altered Carbon" (based on a book) featuring an AI using Edgar Allan Poe as their persona.
That Edgar Allan Poe is seminal in both genres makes me appreciate an already amazing character that much more! I would 10/10 recommend anyone watch season one of the series.
This thread now has me tempted to finally get into reading Poe himself, (among Lovecraft and the Altered Carbon books for more Poe influenced writing).
bmm6o
What's interesting is that Poe is not in the Altered Carbon book. The hotel was called the Hendrix and its avatar was Jimi the guitarist. They couldn't get image rights for the film, so had to change it. But i agree that atmospherically and thematically Poe is a better fit.
defrost
You might also enjoy Flow Like Poe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j8Z0VynTR84
keiferski
I took a detective fiction course in college and Rue Morgue was indeed the first story we read.
shortrounddev2
He was also the primary influence on HP Lovecraft
ndsipa_pomu
Absolutely. I think that's more well known though, he wrote that Poe was his "God of fiction". His influence on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, Jules Verne and H G Wells is probably less well know. He was also a big influence on Alfred Hitchcock who wrote "It's because I liked Edgar Allan Poe's stories so much that I began to make suspense films".
TheAtomic
Someone should summarize for Poe fans who don't support WaPo.
gcheong
Maybe just read the article through the archive link instead?
ssake
I've discovered that Edgar Allan Poe's claim to "The Raven" was a scam. He actually had nothing to do with either writing it, or with its premiere publication. He merely scooped it by three days, replacing the real author's pseudonym with his own name. The real author had been Mathew Franklin Whittier, younger brother of the Quaker poet John Greenleaf Whittier, who wrote it based on real-life circumstances. You can find my evidence and argument at this URL: https://www.academia.edu/49095038/Evidence_that_Edgar_Allan_...
slowtrek
Was just reading about Churchill's alcoholism in a bio and looks like Poe was right there with him on that front. My favorite Poe visual is the The Masque of the Red Death. Probably wrote it blasted out of his mind.
lqet
I was mildly interested in poetry as an adolescent, and "discovering" Poe in the English original (I was only aware of bad translations) had quite an impact on my young, impressionable brain. I still have large parts of "The Raven" and "Annabel Lee" memorized, 20 years later. After Poe, it was hard for me to take writers seriously who just inserted line breaks into prose texts and called it poetry.
shreyshnaccount
It's a good article, but the headline feels a bit off considering the source. The idea of personal responsibility has been co-opted by corporations in the past to deflect from systemic issues, so seeing it framed this way- especially given the ownership and agenda of WP- feels a little manipulative. Though, to be fair, I am almost certainly over-analyzing it.
iaaan
Not at all, I think it's certainly worth pointing out. Regular people (like the author of this article, presumably) often end up inadvertently parroting the agendas that have been instilled into them, consciously or not.
I produced CC0 ebook compilations of Poe’s short fiction and poetry for Standard Ebooks if anyone is interested in diving deeper into his writing: https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/edgar-allan-poe
(I’d also recommend Leonid Andreyev’s short fiction; he’s often referred to as Russia’s Poe: https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/leonid-andreyev/short-fict... )