BYD to offer Tesla-like self-driving tech in all models for free
155 comments
·February 11, 2025hnburnsy
999900000999
Its all about milking Americans for more money.
Without all the trade restrictions, you could buy a BYD EV for 10k. It's not the greatest car ever, but it would be a cool city car. Naw, better go and pay 40k for a worse American version.
Temu is getting basically banned. It's not enough I pay around 40% of my income on in taxes and healthcare insurance, I now much pay higher prices for the same stuff on Amazon.
bamboozled
It’s free market capitalism. At least they’re deleting the government. That should save you a few dollars, right ?
judge2020
Given their M/O is seemingly using indentured Uighur servants, it probably wouldn’t work economically here.
https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/chines...
hnburnsy
Well at least we are protecting those automotive union jobs so that the average MSRP can top $50K.
999900000999
Thank God we never do that here.
>Intricate, invisible webs, just like this one, link some of the world’s largest food companies and most popular brands to jobs performed by U.S. prisoners nationwide, according to a sweeping two-year AP investigation into prison labor that tied hundreds of millions of dollars’ worth of agricultural products to goods sold on the open market.
https://apnews.com/article/prison-to-plate-inmate-labor-inve...
Mr-Frog
I read the article and while it definitely seems like visa abuse, I saw no reference to Uyghur people. I think you are conflating several issues here.
Freedom2
Isn't prison labor a large part of some town's economies? Sounds like it could work just fine, so your assertion is false.
bdunks
I was in Mexico City two weeks ago and a few uber drivers were driving BYD Dolphins. I was impressed. At a $14k price point, I can’t imagine better value for money. I got sucked into research and there are no near term plans for expanding to the US market. It’s too bad. They’re expecting to sell 500,000 units in Mexico this year. With the current (lower) emissions standards, I’m optimistic such affordable EVs will make a big difference to air quality in the coming years.
haunter
>At a $14k price point
In China maybe where it's 100k RMB (~roughly $14k). Everywhere else it's the double or at least $25k. It's £26k ($32k) in the UK. It's €32k ($33k) in Germany
Even in Mexico it's $26k (535k pesos) not $14k https://www.autocosmos.com.mx/catalogo/vigente/byd/dolphin
pfd1986
Just did a quick check and it translates to $30K in Brazil as well
kawera
Entry level Dolphins cost $20.5k in Brazil (R$118k).
wdb
And in Singapore it’s US$120k. Not much more than Tesla or Mercedes etc
rainsford
I'll admit I don't quite understand how EV demand works in lower income countries like Mexico. One of the major limits I see in the US is that the main appeal of having an EV is reasonably good (i.e. level 2) charging at home, which isn't an available option for many people in the US who don't have private garages with good electrical service. I feel like this limitation would be even more widespread in a country like Mexico, but maybe that's either incorrect or the appeal of EVs outside of the US doesn't rely quite so much on charging at home.
femto
Having just bought an EV, the charging requirements seem to be exaggerated. I'm able to put a bit over 100km range into the car with an overnight charge (9 hours) from a standard power point that can deliver 2.4kW. I'm just using a portable 10A/240V plug-in charger: no fixed infrastructure.
My typical charging regime is: charge to 80%. Drive until the car has done 100km (down to ~50% capacity), then charge back up to 80%. If we go over 100km in a day the car drops below 50%. That can't be topped up in a single night, but it just means the charging accumulates over the next few nights until it's back to 80%. It works as long as the average is less than 100km per day and the peak is less than 300km per day.
Whilst it wouldn't do for a taxi, it's perfectly okay for the driving we do.
torginus
Solar is super cheap nowadays - you can have a complete 5kW solar install with an 5kWh battery for around $2000 + labor. I'd argue a similar proportion of people have their own houses.
Additionally, a level 2 charger is just a high amperage wall socket plus some safety equipment.
heyjamesknight
Unless your commute is long, charging overnight on a standard outlet is more than sufficient. We have two EVs—one for my daily ~50 mile round trip commute while the other stays in the neighborhood most the time—and we never have to charge outside the home.
testfrequency
I was just about to comment that a friend of mine owns a BYD and I got to drive his while in Mexico. Can’t remember the model, but it’s a crossover style.
I was ready to hate on it, but for the price and quality inside at least, wild. It also drove like any other car in the low/mid range that I’ve owned, wheel felt confident and had some heft to it (my preference).
vitaflo
They’re not coming to the US market because there’s a 100% tariff on Chinese EVs. Biden signed that last year.
lesuorac
Isn't 14k with a 100% tariff still way cheaper than a Tesla?
boredatoms
Is it possible to import them from Mexio to US as a used-car?
beau_g
Nope, there's a 25 year import rule on cars that aren't homologated for US market https://carbuzz.com/features/25-year-import-rule-everything-...
bagels
It's infinity years in California.
cpursley
Only after 25 years.
null
adrr
US doesn't have a large demand for EVs so I doubt we'll see BYD in the US. They are building a factory in Mexico that is capable of 300,000 vehicles per year.
slashdev
Not sure where you get that info from.
Demand is also relative to price and US EVs are very expensive.
adrr
"“We’re not planning to come to the US,” Stella Li, executive vice president of BYD and CEO of BYD Americas, told Yahoo Finance Live (video above). “It’s an interesting market, but it is very complicated,” she added, citing growing political pushback on Chinese companies and the slowing rate of growth for EV adoption."
From the largest maker of BEVs.
bradgessler
Why are US EVs 2-3x the cost of BYD EVs? Do US consumers not want cars at that price point, is it regulation, is to labor/material costs, or some combination thereof?
It seems like if there was a $15-$20k EV in the US market, it would be a no-brainer "around town" second car.
Instead we get $30k Model 3/Y's or $80k EV SUV/Vans.
cladopa
Subsidies. Basically all savers in China that have money in the bank have to pay for development of what the central Government considers a priority, like steel and aluminium production, solar panels or EV vehicles, or chip manufacturing.
Aluminium and steel costs significantly less in China than the rest of the world, but they now face significant problems because of overcapacity. There are so much factories built and so small demand companies can not survive without help from the Government. They were build thanks to cheap loans from the Government.
So the Government made an investment that is not making money, so basically is a transfer of wealth from bank savers account to industry.
This is also applied in the US and EU, let's remember interest rates below inflation, "Quantitative Easing" and other transfers of wealth the central banks do in the West.
Tesla was also subsidised.
seanmcdirmid
Nissan Leaf now starts at $28k. Chevy Bolt is now $26.5k (was, now discontinued). Given that the dolphin goes for $21k in Mexico, it isn't a huge price diff, definitely not 2-3x. Not sure where you see Model 3 for just $30k, it starts at $40k in the USA. Only in China does a model 3 cost $32k.
tzs
> Not sure where you see Model 3 for just $30k, it starts at $40k in the USA
Probably from Tesla.com. It lists the long range RWD cash price as $29920 (in my state) unless you notice the checked checkbox that says "Include est. incentives of $7,500 and 5-year gas savings of $<whatever> for <your_state>" an uncheck it.
$whatever is $5000 for my state.
_huayra_
> Nissan Leaf now starts at $28k.
Kinda missing the point that you get 50% more range in the Dolphin, plus a lot of additional niceties / tech stuff that is just not available in the Leaf.
klooney
https://www.tesla.com/model3 says "From $29,9901"
kmonsen
Isn’t that including tax breaks? Yes after checking the cheapest is $42k the advertised price includes 7500 tax break and 5000 in gas savings.
42772827
Labor costs and a manufacturing industry that isn’t hyperfinancialized by the government
plantwallshoe
There are tons of used Leafs online for under 8k USD that still have a range of 60-100 miles. Perfect around town car but the price seems to reflect that no one wants one.
hedora
Early Leafs ate batteries, so the really cheap used ones often need a potentially unavailable replacement battery.
You can easily get a used EV in good working order for under $15K though: https://insideevs.com/features/715984/best-used-evs-on-a-bud...
reaperducer
It seems like if there was a $15-$20k EV in the US market, it would be a no-brainer "around town" second car.
Every few months Electrek publishes a list of EVs that can be leased in the United States for under $200/month. Sometimes they're as cheap as $99 or even $0/month, depending on your state's incentives.
xyst
American companies have been using the excuse of “more technology/screens” to justify the higher price points. Then using vague “inflation”/“pandemic”/“supply chain issues” to justify higher prices.
However as we witnessed during the pandemic, manufacturers of goods tend to increase the cost of the goods despite minimal increase in supply chain, cost of materials or labor. It’s all for maximizing profit and they were “testing” the market to reap massive profits.
With no competition, they (collectively as an industry) felt no need to decrease prices or offer cheaper vehicle options.
I also suspect abuse of CAFE exceptions (ie, “light duty trucks”) is the second leading cause of the death of affordable vehicles.
gibolt
BYD also charges ~double the price in other markets, including Mexico, compared to China. That makes it very close to a base Model 3, for much less car.
ggm
This seems like doing a lot of +++ on one side and --- on the other, to say "its cheaper, for a cheaper car"
1) it's not as expensive as a model 3 in mexico
2) it's not as much lower end, when it comes to what drivers want, noting FSD is not actually on anyones radar, or "free" with the low end models
3) it's cheaper by a margin most people on rational incomes close to average would say is a LOT of money.
mikl
One might hope it’ll cause Tesla to drop the price for their “full” self-driving too. $8'000 for a software feature is just bonkers. Especially in Europe, where there’s no subscription option, so you can’t even try it without paying the full price first, and many of the fancier features are not supported here. Even regular auto-pilot is not very reliable for me, it often fails to recognize city limits signs, and fairly often panic brakes because it misinterprets cars driving on the other side of the road as being on collision course.
highfrequency
You can bet that the 100% tariff on BYD cars in the US isn’t going anywhere with Musk so influential in the government. A $14k EV would be a huge threat to Tesla’s market cap.
hnburnsy
>You can bet that the 100% tariff on BYD cars in the US isn’t going anywhere with Musk...
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cq55zd2xjreo
>Musk opposes US tariffs on Chinese electric cars. "In fact, I was surprised when they were announced. Things that inhibit freedom of exchange or distort the market are not good," Mr Musk said on Thursday. “Tesla competes quite well in the market in China with no tariffs and no deferential support. I’m in favour of no tariffs," he added.
Cyph0n
That was in May of last year. A lot has changed since then.
filoeleven
> 23 May, 2024
bagels
Musk says a lot of things that are not true. Hard to know if that was a serious take.
senordevnyc
Musk seems significantly more unhinged today than he did nine months ago.
notatoad
even if the tariff did disappear, i can't imagine BYD is going to be too eager to get into the US market. there's plenty of other places to sell cars.
SauciestGNU
I think rest of world will gobble these up though, especially with retaliatory tariffs or straight up import bans on Teslas on the table from aggrieved trading partners.
IncreasePosts
I'm just waiting for the inevitable fallout that seems to come with most trump advisors to buy BYD stock.
modeless
Let's not blame the current administration for tariffs that Biden imposed.
xyst
To me, tariffs from the orange man are political theater and appeal to his base, and subsequently sell it via media.
What’s to stop manufacturers of goods from shipping it from a country that is not China, laundering it through a different country. Paper work for container says, “imported from {non tariff restricted country}” at the ship yard.
Cheap Chinese goods still flood the market. Orange man gets to say he has been hard on China via tariff war.
atlintots
In fact, the tariffs on BYD cars were imposed by the Biden administration.
hathawsh
OTOH, theoretically, could we produce a decently priced EV with US materials only? If we go all-in on automation, could one factory worker do the job that many do today, thereby reducing costs? If we can head in that direction, I think Elon wants to compete in that kind of market, not bog it down with regulation.
callc
Sure. Price every good from not-USA 1000x and let’s see what happens.
I thought the republicans were in favor of a free market, but it seems more like those with power don’t mind putting some weight on their side of the scale, since they own the scale and the bank.
> I think Elon wants to compete in that kind of market, not bog it down with regulation
Be careful about any phrase that starts with “I think {person} wants to…” especially if person is rich/powerful. Judge people based on their actions, not the facade they put on.
hn_acc1
> I think Elon wants to compete in that kind of market, not bog it down with regulation.
Exactly what market is that? Where Tesla has 0 responsibility for any issues / defects / deaths-from-FSD? Sure, that market he wants to play in - it has only upside for him.
The one where he has to compete on price/features/whatever, and he can't make rude comments or cut people off who he doesn't like? Please pass the bong..
uptownfunk
So what is tslas new story going to be at earnings.
nova22033
"Tesla-like" meaning not really "Full" self driving?
0xcoffee
>BYD has deployed three different versions of the “God’s Eye” ADAS across its line-up. All three offer automated parking and lane-keeping features, with the basic version – available on models costing up to 219,800 yuan ($30,078.69) – enabling autonomous driving on highways. The driver must keep their hands on the wheel and take control when necessary.
>Two higher-end versions will be installed on more expensive BYD-branded cars and its premium Denza and Yangwang brands. These will enable a car to drive autonomously — though also under human supervision — in more complex urban traffic.
The base version is self driving as in lane assist. It will not change lanes for you or 'self drive' to your destination.
I agree with BYD that these are great safety features and give them props for not gating safety behind a paywall.
null
gregschlom
A bit surprised to learn that their product is called "God's eyes", given that this is a Chinese company - I thought religion was frowned upon in Communist China. Am I missing something?
GuB-42
You don't have to believe in god to call your product "god's eyes" anymore than you have to believe in dragons to use the word "dragon".
If anything, I would consider using the word "god" in a commercial tech product to be disrespectful to an actual believer.
zozbot234
The really nice thing about this is that every single accident that the system gets into will have to be classed as an "Act of God".
harry8
The religious are more likely to object to this name. One can imagine a different name in Saudi, for example.
Among atheists one would think it would no more troubling than referencing Legolas in a name. [1]
In China I suspect they'd object to "Mao's Eyes" as a name for this.
[1] Many atheists may register an objection on the grounds of upsetting others in the community.
Terr_
Mysticism in general is fine, you just can't be a political rival.
Plus, like in English, there are a ton of words people use more for the poetic impressiveness than because they're specifically asserting a supernatural power.
sympil
Obviously there are people who don’t believe in god who use that word in phrases to convey a certain sense or meaning.
cozzyd
Atheists can't iddqd
gjsman-1000
All religions not approved by the party are frowned upon in China.
Also, when a religion refuses to gain approval, the party quite literally hard forks it. Catholic? No, you have the Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association; which was only recently tentatively reconciled after about 60 years of schism (though it’s still a very uneasy peace).
null
amazingamazing
> I thought religion was frowned upon in Communist China. Am I missing something?
What gave you this idea?
hathawsh
I would love to hear someone refute this:
https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/10/23/10-things...
Especially point #8, "The ruling Chinese Communist Party promotes atheism and discourages citizens from practicing religion"
amazingamazing
I see. There’s not much to refute, the country doesn’t really promote so much organized religion. You should go to Beijing though, I definitely saw Christians there, and Chinese culture also has many elements of Taoism embedded even if they’re generally atheist.
jongjong
Surely they cannot sell at this price without government subsidies?
This possibility paints a clear picture of the power of government in the global marketplace. The government of any large country can selectively choose to monopolize any specific industry and wipe out all competitors in other countries via subsidies.
It's not a fair playing field for market participants. It makes the whole environment completely unpredictable and dominated by the whims of hundreds of different governments. It promotes government scheming over raw productive capabilities of workers and entrepreneurs; it throws decentralized economic efficiency under the bus in favor of monopolistic, centralized government-oriented strategies.
In such environment, I can understand why tariffs are essential. You can't have a market where participants are playing by different rules. Also, you can't expect market participants to familiarize themselves with the secret policies of hundreds of different governments or be forced to abandon their entire industry in their own country because they happen to be skilled in an industry which is not propped up in their own country as it is in some other foreign country.
Our system is so incredibly asymmetric, right down to the monetary layer. People ought to refuse to participate at all. Maybe that's the point. Chinese communist party isn't exactly aiming for a capitalist utopia with a level playing field.
Despegar
Tesla would be fucked without tariffs.
xp84
Would you want for all cars to be made in China, the way all computers and smartphones are? I can't imagine any other outcome.
nimos
Instead lets have them made in a place that has threatened to take over ~4 sovereign nations in the past three weeks? Yeah I'll take the 1/2 price cars thanks.
xp84
Can you in any way separate in your mind the idea of the USA as a nation of 300,000,000 people, who need jobs and who all benefit from having safe and good quality cars, from the trolling actions of a few politicians?
With statements like yours, it feels like the left is rooting for the most catastrophic outcomes possible for that whole country, just to spite Trump. Even though we'd all lose and Trump wouldn't be affected either way.
porphyra
I don't mind having all my computers and smartphones made in China. And I didn't mind when both cars and electronics were made in Japan.
sockaddr
You consider technological/economic dominance by Japan or China to be equivalent threat classes?
kevin_thibedeau
Japan hit its peak before surveillance capitalism became pervasive. They also categorically fail at developing complex software. The Chinese won't make that mistake.
loloquwowndueo
That’s how the free market works, right?
Dig1t
Yes it certainly is.
You can see the effects of the free market in many industries which have been decimated by globalization.
We used to be able to get a manufacturing job which would provide for a family, but decided it was okay to allow big corps to use slave labor on the other side of the planet and just ship everything across the world (not great for carbon emissions). Just look at the rust belt.
It’s not a bad idea to say that we should have the free market stop at our border. Other countries don’t play by the same rules that we do and can even have entire industries propped up by a foreign government in order to take up market share.
sergiotapia
has to be both ways for that to work. china can't just do whatever and tariff american companies to hell, right?
tokioyoyo
Even if we consider "China is funding the companies to no end" argument... well, frankly, I wish US would do the same. It is pretty damn cool to see incredible technological progress in huge scale.
tayo42
There's different cars for different needs. F150 is the best selling vehicle in the US even though there are cheaper pick ups and cars in general.
There is alot if variety for cars. The US market can't be the only market keeping every European and Asian car manufacturer in business.
cute_boi
Yes, if it means I would have to buy car that costs an arms and a leg like tesla.
Despegar
Yeah I don't care
j7ake
Companies shouldn’t be taking handouts from the US government.
Let capitalism dictate where the cars get made. It is the American way.
seanmcdirmid
Tesla sells a lot of cars in China (made in China) and exports lots of cars it makes in China to countries like Australia.
mikl
So would all the other western automakers. The lower wage- and energy costs in China would strangle them all.
outlace
All American car companies would be
werdnapk
It's more the sanctions than the tariffs.
throwaway5752
Tesla is fucked.
On 12/17/24 they hit a 52 week high around $490 per share. Since then, in less than two months, they have lost one third of their value. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/TSLA/
Musk has single-handedly alienated his core domestic buying demographic in favor of a group that, when polled, says they would not consider an EV at rates of around 70%.
EU markets in which TSLA was viable but contested are even worse.
This while Tesla's strongest international competitor is passing on units sold, executing better, and underpricing them.
As someone who has followed Tesla since the Model S, previously held Musk in some regard, and test drove a Model 3 I find this such an abject travesty of an outcome for what should have been a great US based global car maker and someone who had the potential to accomplish such good for the world with their incredible wealth and privilege.
tokioyoyo
To my understanding, the ridiculous stock price and valuation have absolutely nothing to do with the car business. It's basically the potential hopes and dreams of what the leadership can do with direct access to US government.
sockaddr
Yup. And don't buy the line that Elon made Tesla a success. They had the core tech and talent to build an EV (without all the other bullshit he added) before he came along. Given enough time they could have been something on their own too.
amazingamazing
> Given enough time they could have been something on their own too.
This is based off what? Couldn’t this be argued for literally any company?
dlivingston
This is most definitely not true. Tesla was barely more than an electric powertrain and battery combo when Musk took over. The first production Roadsters even reused the chassis from Porsche 911s (IIRC).
Other US competitors aren't at parity with Tesla or BYD. Nikola went bust. Legacy automakers turned out mediocre EVs. Rivian is the only true competitor, but they are a luxury brand and don't have Tesla's crown jewel (the Supercharger network).
Watch Out of Spec for reviews of the latest Chinese EV tech including ADAS and battery swapping...
https://outofspecstudios.com/
I was floored by what they are producing in China. It is a shame that these cars are not reaching more of the world and raising the competitive bar. I get the government subsidy and lower labor costs issues, but the tariffs are retarding competition, propping up prices, and hurting consumers.