The Creative Power of Constraints
8 comments
·May 5, 2025gwern
zhenpixels
You caught me. Will do.
dvh
If you ask random people to draw a horse, they will give you excuses why they can't draw. Tell them to draw horse using only rectangles and suddenly everybody is a painter.
betterThanTexas
That's actually pretty interesting insight into painting (to me, anyway).
kunzhi
For anyone interested in more constraint reading, highly highly recommend Notes on the Synthesis of Form by Christopher Alexander.
IMHO it should be required reading for all programmers and designers.
zhenpixels
Great suggestion. Just bought it.
recursivedoubts
"The enemy of art is the absence of limitations" --Orson Welles
alganet
Remember when this idea bred those fake minimalist preachers? Mistaking constraint-based design for asceticism?
Too much constraints, you end up in a corner.
It reminds me of Windows Metro. That was good constraint-based design. Lots of clever thinking in the good direction. Windows 8 was great (hey, Apple copied some of it, the highest form of praise).
Eames was smart. Translating those things to tech is often a challenge. Keeping the thing human is difficult.
> Charles Eames’s distinction between forced compromises and willingly accepted constraints reveals a profound truth — in the delicate balance between structure and freedom lies the sweet spot where creativity thrives.
Suggested constraint: "write this post without AI".