Intentionally Making Close Friends (2021)
100 comments
·April 8, 2025parpfish
ryangittins
> ...getting insecure or jealous of all the other social connections that your extrovert friends have. There’s an asymmetry there that can feed lots of insecurities.
I wouldn't sweat this too much. Mathematically, most people have fewer friends than their friends have.
manmal
I don’t fully understand how this is a paradox. I guess it’s based on the fact that there are „super nodes“ in human social networks, where one person has many friends, while most others don’t? Or is there anything more to it?
arduanika
It's the more expansive definition of paradox, meaning something like "counterintuitive result". In expectancy, a randomly chosen person has an average number of friends. You might therefore think that a random person and their friends, all of whom seem randomly chosen, would have the same expected number of friends. But you'd be wrong, because the friends weren't random after all: they had at least one friend. Not a logical paradox, but a surprising fact.
BobbyTables2
Found the EE!
robocat
The counter-intuitiveness is partially to averaging. Averages often deceive our intuitions.
fellowniusmonk
There is a fun but rare kind of humanist that doesn't think they are special but are curious about others, see the value in randos they meet and thinks that _others_ are special and they really _listen_, you know?
Pretty sure its just that they all have superior statistical intuition.
kaashif
I used to feel insecure or jealous of the number of friends these people have, but years ago I realized that I would find their lives exhausting and terrible. And vice versa, they'd hate the amount of time I spend on my own doing stuff.
parpfish
For me it’s not that I want to have a ton of friends like they do, it’s more that I worry about how we each perceive the relative importance of the relationship. E.g., they are one of five friends to me; I’m one of 50 friends to them.
robrenaud
Find some nerdy social hobby, become part of a community. Board games, killer queen arcade, and indoor rock climbing have all been a bridge to some close friendships for me.
jayd16
>I’m sure that there’s something equivalent from the other direction, but I dont know what it is
There's a risk of becoming a people pleaser or letting people down. People expect you to manage the party or the outing or whatever.
There's fear that the many relationships you have are shallow. Even in this post your suggestion is to simply use the extrovert to get to a real friend you actually want.
Direct insecurity of what people "actually" think of you is still there, I'm sure.
That said, people are usually thinking about their own problems and what people think of them a lot more than what they think of you so just relax a bit.
red_admiral
Int-to-int pairs are more likely to form in nature at specific watering holes.
For example, EA/rationalist is not quite my kind of community (altough I think highly of many of their writings), but an ACX meetup looks like a good place for introverts of a particular kind to come together.
I guess the trick is to find the right kind of place first.
aleph_minus_one
For those who are out of the loop:
EA: Effective Altruism (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effective_altruism )
ACX: Astral Codex Ten; see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACX https://www.astralcodexten.com/
LW (used at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43663979 ): Less Wrong
williamcotton
If you like reading HN then you’d probably enjoy an LW meetup!
flawn
Ughh, LessWrong is a bit more of a rationalist cult than anything - and I say that as somebody who is in the AIS & EA space. It's a huge problem that fields like AI Safety happen on that forum, as "normies" really get scared off by the stuff that's on there.
cma
These days they are more of racialist scientism meet & greet
riehwvfbk
Who'd want to miss out on joining the next Zizians!
nothrabannosir
There's nothing equivalent from the other direction.
- extrovert
(/s ;))
aptj
Ah, you b--tard stealing my hard-earned friends! ;))
But seriously, is this how some insecure introverts also bond around those charismatic sociopaths and then help'em ruin the world while quietly working for the XYZ agencies? /s
parpfish
I think that’s just insecure people in general, unless extroverts have an ability I don’t know about that makes them immune to charming sociopaths
bhasi
I have a childhood friend that I went to school with for all of my school days. Ever since school days, we find the same obscure things funny and always end up in splits whenever we talk. To this day, I don't have this with any other friend.
We had a few years' gap of not really being in touch during undergrad but that changed as we had a few months' overlap at post-grad university. It was easier to meet after that and we did keep in touch, but I felt that he was holding back somewhat and not really being free with his thoughts, letting the conversation flag at times.
So at a friend's wedding a couple of years ago, I opened up to him and plainly told him that it's a shame we don't talk as we used to as we both are clearly on the same wavelength when it comes to shared interests and sense of humour. And this worked - our degree of friendship has increased an order of magnitude since before that time. I would have lost a great friend to the vagaries of life had I not taken that step to become vulnerable for an instant then.
manapause
My first job out of college I was hired to follow around an MSP/IT consultant and learn what he did, specifically to cut the expense of having a MCSA/network engineer coming in weekly for basic desktop support.
I met him in the server closet and asked “hey, I’m new here - do you mind if I look over your shoulder?” He turned around and smiled, “if you are here to help, then you should sit down and I’ll walk you through setting up Exchange mailboxes for these doctors.” Before he left, he walked me through a RAM upgrade and gave me his lucky red screwdriver “ you got this, just call me if you have any issues.”
Later in my career, I continue to learn lessons from this interaction; lately the lesson has been one of “don’t be awesome in a vacuum” - a little bit of encouragement to the new guy can go a long way to adding another person to your on-call rotation that you trust.
20 years later, I still have his screwdriver - and I bring it every time we have lunch every once in a while.
Life is too short to not let the people who make life enjoyable for us know so.
w10-1
Mutual sacrifice is the glue that takes time to set.
Mutual interest propels activity, but reliable sacrifice is the basis of trust and reliance.
But if you are perceived as welching on this, you will induce real and lasting anger, justifiably in my mind because you’ve just made it harder for people to trust for the rest of their lives.
And this is not limited to close friends.
A girlfriend’s mom’s advice: trust your man only after he’s crawled over a mile of broken glass, and your boss when he’s done it underwater.
daymanstep
Following your girlfriend's mom's advice, you wouldn't trust anyone.
Maybe that's why so few people have friends these days: they set some crazy/impossible conditions that you have to meet before they will trust you. As an autistic person it's impossible for me to guess what kind of crazy requirements I have failed to meet.
brianpan
Similar journey in book form: Sorry I'm Late, I Didn't Want to Come. Introvert Jessica Pan spends a year being an extrovert.
https://bookshop.org/p/books/sorry-i-m-late-i-didn-t-want-to...
MortyWaves
I’ve been trying to make friends, it’s hard as an introvert. Tried a few times online to meet a wider group of people but as per other comments here people often “ghost” or don’t return the effort I’ve tried to put in.
I absolutely feel moving around as a child a dozen times meant I never formed any lasting friendships from schools, which then had knock on effects in college, and then university.
conception
For me, as a non-introvert, I had to come to the realization that most people just won’t reciprocate at a level I want. That you just have to make the stuff happen that you want to happen. So, you really can’t wait for people to reach out to you. If you want to spend time with someone or if you want to have a group outing you just have to be the one to do it. It’s kinda like any club Ive been a part in. There’s usually a few people that drive things, organize, etc and most freeload off that. Your friendships will be like that too. You might find another driver and that’s great! But it won’t be the case most of the time. And it won’t be because people don’t want to do things, it’s just how people are. I wouldn’t take offense. Just think they aren’t gonna be the vice president of your friend club and they’ll just be a member and that’s okay too. Y’all still have a good time.
sethammons
Growing up, it seemed the kids that moved a lot, aka military brats, were often good at finding new friends. More practice I assumed.
appleorchard46
I'm in the same boat, friend. Being exposed to so much has its upsides but ability to make lasting relationships is not one of them.
acsquared
I got into open source software back in 2023, and by far the best part of it has been the community around the code. From irl to irc, some of my closest friends I've made since then I've met through programming.
croisillon
Related (Nov 2022 - 307 comments): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33774353
Uzmanali
I used to wait for people to talk to me. But now I try first, and it works!
mrexroad
Hi, what are your hobbies?
null
legerdemain
Do you come here often? I haven't seen you here before! I LIKE YOUR SHOES!
johnecheck
Okay story time.
A friend in college is sitting at a bus stop. Somebody sits next to him, says "hey I like your shoes", strikes up a conversation. Ends up inviting him to a business/networking seminar.
My friend goes, comes back with a book and is saying all kinds of stuff about passive income and how you gotta take control of your finances.
I google the book name, the second result is a reddit thread about how somebody at a bus stop had their shoes complimented and then got recruited for the same thing. Turns out it was Amway.
So, yeah. 'I like your shoes' works well enough as a conversation starter that it's literally in the pyramid scheme manual.
udev4096
That's boring. How can someone start a conversation like that? It leads to nowhere and the person is now way more disinterested in talking to you. Best way is to talk about books, games, TV shows, etc. It's something you can easily expand upon once you find a common ground
null
bombcar
My name is Dug. I have just met you, and I love you.
SQUIRREL!
Uzmanali
That's a good one.
donatj
I have a small handful of people I would call my friend. Most of them since grade school. Yet, in my life, I have had three people I have really truly opened up to. One of them died suddenly, I miss you Meka. One of them stopped talking to me for reasons I don't understand. One of them cheated on me repeatedly.
I'm just frankly not sure I'll ever truly fully open up to someone again. I have been seeing a therapist for a couple of years now and I still go in with a pretty thick shell I have trouble piercing. I'm so slow to warm up to people, I just really doubt there will be another person in my life I'll ever be around enough to get to that point with. Work from home for the last five years has not helped that at all.
Being an adult just kinda sucks.
gonzobonzo
> One of them stopped talking to me for reasons I don't understand.
This is relatively common from what I've seen. People who just ghost a friend, or ghost an entire groups of friends. A lot of the times it's because they're unhappy with their life and trying to make a clean break from what they were connected to before.
pjerem
I’m sorry for what happened to you.
I don’t know if it can comfort you but personally I’m trying to accept that it’s ok to be "vulnerable" with mostly everyone. Most of the time it creates interesting bonds with people. Sometimes you are being "vulnerable" to authentic jerks and so what ? Most of the time you can just ignore them.
I find that acting like this is actually an effective automatic filter for my social interactions.
The only place I’m more protecting myself (without being totally closed) is at work because, probably due to the environment, people aren’t acting normally at work.
KittenInABox
One of the things I've noticed is that there is a huge discrepancy between people who can "bounce back" from someone behaving inappropriately to them when they are in a vulnerable position. People who are able to go "yeah fuck you too buddy, anyways onto the next thing" are way more able to handle things. People who end up dwelling on one person who did something bad years ago and are unable to let go of that pain end up closing themselves off for fear of exacerbating it.
pjerem
Yeah but like I said, I’m just trying to do that. I’ve been like the former people you described.
In my case, I feel it’s just the wisdom of just being older. I also have the luck of having a stable life, a few friends and nice little family. I’ve never been more emotionally stable than today so of course it’s much easier not to care when people randomly betray me.
SoftTalker
Sort of the same. I’ve lost touch with or been sabotaged by the people I used to be close to. Now I have acquaintances, people I know and am fine hanging out with, but I don’t have anyone close that I’d really trust or open up to. And I’m fine with that, the effort it takes and the risks of being very open with someone are not worth it to me. And if someone tries to open up to me, I’m immediately suspicious and will start to distance myself. At this point in my life I’m not interested in taking on someone else’s emotional baggage.
user68858788
It’s an awful feeling to have a trusted friend distance themselves with no explanation. It amplifies any insecurities we have.
I hope you find someone you can connect with. I’m rooting for you man.
QuantumGood
Sorry about your losses, especially Meka. Showing up for therapy is courageous. That's not small.
aaarrm
It's not as hard as you think to get close to people, but you have to be intentional about it.
First step would be to widen your "funnel" of new people in your life before then filtering them down. Simply need to go to social events, meetups, etc.
01HNNWZ0MV43FF
I believe there are lots of people I'd open up to, but it's complicated because I would want to sleep with them
rufus_foreman
>> up until about 4 years ago, I didn’t have any close friends in my life. I had friends, but struggled to form real emotional connections. Moreover, it didn’t even occur to me that I could try to do this. It wasn’t that I knew how to form close friends but was too anxious to try, rather, ‘try to form close friendships’ was a non-standard action, something that never even crossed my mind
It's the same thing with enemies. If you're an introvert like me, it's really hard to make true enemies, as opposed to people that just vaguely dislike you. You might have to go pretty far out of your comfort zone to do it. For many people, similar to what the author says, it will never even cross their minds. But it can be oddly rewarding.
stroz
Loved this. The shift from waiting for connection to intentionally building it is everything — and it’s exactly why we built Soonly (https://soonly.com). Most people rely on serendipity, Soonly makes it a habit. It’s an operating system for intentional connections.
Dansvidania
being open, honest and as a consequence sometimes vulnerable in conversations -1 to 1 or not- without overly filtering myself to stay appropriate or to protect my ego or image has brought me to having a number of close friendship that I would not have thought possible.
Those people that I now consider my family made me a better person and I would even argue made me into an adult.
I would simplify this in 1 don't be afraid to ask random questions 2 be sincerely interested in knowing about the other person's answer
I find this easier to do when the people are evidently interesting, but more often than not people are interesting after I exercise some curiosity about them.
As an introvert that’s been consciously working to make new friends, I’ve noticed a couple phenomena:
- I’d love to be friends with other introverts to enjoy quiet times together. but… int-to-int pairs will rarely form in nature, however extroverts are great for mediating the connections. Make friends with the talkative outgoing types, because through them you can meet the other quiet people they’ve befriended but you’d never meet in the wild.
- however, there seem to be some common pitfalls to introvert-extrovert friendships. From my (introvert) side, you can often find yourself getting insecure or jealous of all the other social connections that your extrovert friends have. There’s an asymmetry there that can feed lots of insecurities. I’m sure that there’s something equivalent from the other direction, but I dont know what it is