Scientists find links between Alzheimer's, herpes, and head trauma
88 comments
·January 31, 2025jamal-kumar
mrtesthah
The current best effort at curing HSV by way of gene-editing out the latent virus from infected cells is being conducted by the Fred Hutch center. You can donate to their research here:
https://secure.fredhutch.org/site/TR?px=1802786&pg=personal&...
In the meantime, taking anti-virals will reduce the risk of alzheimers:
echelon
Most of the population carries one herpesvirus or another, and those damn things integrate into our nervous system as nuclear plasmids for life. We really should accelerate this line of research.
The herpesvirus family could be causing ADHD, Alzheimer's, MS, and a whole host of other brain diseases. Perhaps even a general cognitive decline in the population.
yakshaving_jgt
Silicon nitride might also be a novel therapy for HSV, if it could perhaps be formulated as a skin scream.
ThePowerOfFuet
[flagged]
BLKNSLVR
So I'm fucked in three ways here. I get cold sores, sometimes in my nose, and as an adolescent playing Aussie rules football I was concussed seven times in two years and once more about fifteen years later (when I took the brutal sport up again for some reason).
There are some "checks in the mail" that could arrive at any time that, if I was the sort of person to worry about the future, would make me worry about the future. But I don't tend to worry, but maybe that's a symptom... I am known to have an incredibly patchy memory; some things stick in great detail, but other things are entirely lost immediately.
As an aside, sun exposure tends to bring on a cold sore 'episode'. Plenty of sunscreen and more specifically lip balm helps prevent it from occurring. But during an Australian summer that requires dedication I haven't quite mastered.
dutchbookmaker
I grew up playing American football and I am pretty well versed on the literature.
I live for now and don't put a lot of stock in having a great life after 65.
In American football, much depends on the position you played. I am not sure how that is for Aussie rules but lineman and linebackers who would be involved in more hits have it worse than wide receivers and cornerbacks. That never seems to be reported with CTE.
The concussion count is mostly non-sense from my understanding. I think this is how the NFL has shaped the narrative to not be so bad and their bogus "concussion protocol". The subconcussive hits are the major problem and that is just part of football. I took at least a thousand of them smashing heads together.
It is also degenerative over time. You aren't going to just wake up one day with problems. If it is really bad you are going to have crazy behavior problems. Like Aaron Hernandez. I am sure OJ Simpson had bad CTE.
I just doubt cold sores are that big of a variable compared to being hit in the head thousands of times.
My memory completely sucks but that has just made me an incredibly good note taker for job related functions.
_DeadFred_
I don't understand how that aren't weight classes in football. I was a 185lb center going up against 300lb nose guards in high school and everyone thought that was ok.
SequoiaHope
I used to get oral cold sores pretty regularly which made dating a drag. It really sucked to be hitting it off with someone and be unable to kiss due to a breakout. I got a prescription for valacyclovir 500mg twice a day and now I never get cold sores. I kiss a lot of people now it’s really nice!
dbspin
Want to second the antiviral. I have a much lower prescription (200mg once a day of the older generic Acyclovir), but I've been using it prophylactically for over twenty years. Each new GP responds with horror, but it reduces my outbreaks from once or twice a month to perhaps three times a year (stress dependent). Given the fact that the more outbreaks you have, the more you will have - everyone with HSV-1 should be on this or similar medication.
__oh_es
Lysine supplements may be something to look into for cold sores. Got a friend who is from SA who doses up on it before and during summer months and she swears by it.
jamal-kumar
Get in on a research study or good doctor who can read the research already done. Don't take too much stock in medical stuff from some rando on hackernews but definitely ask your medical practitioner about these things.
djohnston
So it's APOE-4 + HSV-1 + subsequent head trauma in a model? Interesting, but not particularly shocking - there have been associations with all three of those independently, no?
I'm still waiting for the research community to let the amyloid theory die its long-deserved death and start focusing on tau; hopefully it will restore some momentum towards clinical treatments/prevention.
echelon
I was infected with HSV-1 as an early child (toddler age), and I've suspected it has played a role in ADHD development as well. Not to mention varicella.
> start focusing on tau
The tau hypothesis has been a thing for a long time as well. I wish we'd stop focusing on molecular indications altogether and look at the plausible etiological agents as mechanisms.
The herpesvirus family, certain gut microbiota, blood-brain barrier breaches, immune cell activity, and insulin dysfunction are all incredibly plausible mechanisms that might all somehow contribute or lead to the disease.
bryant
So, I've had this hunch since the very first studies pointing towards the herpes/Alzheimer's link and doubled down on it after the discovery of the "glymphatic fluid" system for essentially washing the brain during sleep. And it's impacted a lot of my social decisions to an almost unhealthy extent, but it's validating to see the research and possible payoff.
My hunch has always been: brain cleans itself. So long as brain cleans itself, infections like herpes and some of the bacteria involved in gingivitis can't trigger the amyloid domino effect that could cause Alzheimer's. But once that cleaning mechanism fails (head trauma), the body can't clean the detritus from the brain fighting the infection anymore. Apoe4's association with boosted hsv outbreaks factored in as well.
I'm oversimplifying it and am probably taking wild stabs in the dark, but I'm hoping the avoidance of high risk behaviors ends up paying off.
But the next question is whether this is all for nothing — if VZV (chickenpox/shingles) ends up having a similar effect... we're already giving our kids weakened VZV vaccines anyway. Seems like the longer term solutions will be:
1) vaccines to prevent hsv/vzv/hhv etc, but they'd end up being love and thus pose a similar but lessened risk
2) ensuring a way to excise the viral DNA from any of these
3) finding a means to rebuild the glymphatic membrane after trauma.
---
My comment is a lot of wild pontification. Any MDs wanna provide a sanity check on anything I said?
hattmall
I'm just wondering how we can stimulate the glymphatic waste clearing system. Like if it is CSF flowing into the brain that removes waste products what can we do to promote that.
I have found that sleeping on the left side and meditation like yoga nidra maybe possible.
But I'm really looking for something like TCDS or a specific exercise or supplement.
magicalhippo
It's always herpes, to paraphrase Dr. House...
What makes herpes so special? The fact that it sticks around?
culi
Herpes has evolved alongside Homo sapiens for millions of years. It's extremely impressively adapted to the human immune system. In fact it can even boost the immune system (maybe in its evolutionary history it found that amping its hosts immune system helped it have less competitors?). In mice it can provide resistance to the bubonic plague
glouwbug
Maybe the fact that everyone has it
onlyrealcuzzo
It's estimated 2/3rds of adults globally have it.
That's a majority, but far from "everyone".
feverzsj
It's just they haven't got the virus yet. Or the viral load is too low to be detectable by current technique.
dsego
And not everyone has bacteria that causes cavities or gingivitis. Seems once you get it, it's difficult to get rid of. I was trying to explain this to my mom (grandma) when she was sharing spoons with our little one, and she was all defensive, like I'm squeamish and it's not a big problem, the kid needs to strengthen her immune system and she's already putting stuff in her mouth, so she will pick it up anyway. It's that boomer/hippie generation that doesn't understand why washing hands was important during covid.
null
ellisv
Seems to be in reference to this article: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39698934/
flobosg
This is the article referred by STAT (unfortunately paywalled): https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/scisignal.ado6430
locusofself
As someone who gets a wicked cold sore every year I always hate hearing about stuff like this. It's terrifying what can happen to babies if you kiss them with HSV-1.
FuckButtons
My mum gave me HSV, she currently has Alzheimer's and has forgotten who everyone, including me is. She is 64.
hattmall
Sorry to hear that, my mom is in similar shape. As is my wife's. Fucking awful.
aussieguy1234
Like the article says, 80% of people have herpes wether they know it or not.
ambicapter
The article says 80% of people aged 60 or over have contracted it at some point, not 80% of people.
01100011
Some people have it, but some people have it worse. Some people get it and build an immune response quickly, limiting the spread it seems. Others don't and the virus seems to take a stronger foothold.
My wife has oral HSV. I don't. We're not careful and we've been together for years with many breakouts. I don't think I've avoided it because I'm magically immune. My guess is that I have it, but I managed to limit it to the degree that I never get a breakout.
Now that I think about it, my wife hasn't had a breakout in two years, pretty much since getting pregnant. Weird.
lazide
I suspect there is a degree of ‘magical immunity’ present for the people who don’t test positive for it.
I know I’ve been exposed countless times from similar experiences, and have always (100% of the time, n==10ish by now) tested negative for it.
Is that so weird? With how prevalent it is, I don’t see how it’s actually possible for <100% of people to not have it otherwise. Unless some large percentage of people are literally living in a bubble, anyway.
p2detar
Pregnancy boosts the immune system, so that may be it. Btw, the amino acid L-Lysine may also help. Many people report positive results on regular intake and one of them is me.
feverzsj
Don't worry. Everyone has the virus.
yieldcrv
we definitely need a way to consider multi variable ailments better
our entire scientific institution and method just tests for one thing, says nope, and dismisses any more complex thought on the subject. unless you do it yourself, which is a very high bar to accomplish
tsimionescu
What would a multi variable model look like where, say, both herpes and plaques contributed to Alzheimer, but you couldn't find proper correlation with either taken individually?
There are plenty of diseases where we have identified multiple risk factors successfully. We have examples of diseases where either risk factor alone is often causative (e.g. pulmonary cancer can be caused by smoking, or by long term asbestos exposure, and if exposed to both, fixing just one won't make the risk very low; and there are of course many other substances that can cause this). And we have also identified diseases where you need two (or sometimes more) separate factors to trigger it (e.g. shingles is a diseases that is triggered in individuals that previously had chickenpox, but generally only if their immune system is weakened by something else, typically old age).
lukan
To complicate things further, Virus can also develope symbiotic traits.
nntwozz
Some evidence suggests that some viral infections such as Herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) may be associated with dementia, but there are conflicting results and the association with Alzheimer's is unclear as of 2024.[95][96][97]
— Wikipedia
jamal-kumar
It will bear out in studies when they start to see whatever results come from giving head injury patients and other at risk groups antivirals to hopefully measurably prevent these conditions from arising
readthenotes1
There's been enough grift in the Alzheimer's research community it's hard to believe anything
yieldcrv
ironic
readthenotes1
And today...
NYT editorial touting a book declaiming the corruption in Alzheimer's research
throwawaymaths
the nhs wales vaccine study is pretty solid
Qem
I thought there was no vaccine for Herpes Simplex.
MLR
The study in Wales and a second study in the US were about herpes zoster (shingles), they both seem to support a link to Alzheimer's and, from what I read, the second study mentions other dementias.
https://alz-journals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.100...
throwawaymaths
and indeed the all causes dementia rate in the study does not go to zero among the vaccinated
quanto
> the latest work addresses one of the biggest criticisms of the microbial theory of Alzheimer’s: HSV-1’s ubiquity. Alzheimer’s impacts only about 10% of the population — if HSV-1 were causing it, why are there so many people who are repositories of the virus but not developing the disease?
That's the rub. Even if this non-traditional brain model is to be taken at face value, there is a missing variable somewhere, arguably more important; HSV-1, at best, would be a contributing factor.
Veserv
I know right. If polio causes paralysis then why do only 0.5% of people who contract polio become paralyzed? Checkmate.
That is mixing up necessary versus sufficient. If all people who develop Alzheimer’s contracted HSV-1 prior to developing Alzheimer’s and all people who did not contract HSV-1 do not develop Alzheimer’s (technically implied by my first statement), then you can make a good case for causality. Obviously you can do better, but that is a good start.
starspangled
> That's the rub. Even if this non-traditional brain model is to be taken at face value, there is a missing variable somewhere, arguably more important; HSV-1, at best, would be a contributing factor.
Did you completely miss the point of the article and even of the quote you copied. "the latest work addresses [this very criticism you have]"?
The article tells us what the missing link is (according to their hypothesis). That's the whole point of it. It's even in the title.
dbetteridge
> Research suggests concussions could awaken latent infections in the brain and lead to dementia
That'd be the suggested missing link, physical impact disturbing dormant virions in the brain or allowing a temporary passage to a part of the brain they're normally unable to reach.
tommiegannert
There was a study published in 2022 suggesting that there's a link between Epstein-Barr and Multiple Sclerosis (where the immune system attacks the neuron insulation layer), and that when you get infected affects the outcome. Cleverly, they used blood samples from US service members, who have to do it multiple times in life.
https://www.science.org/doi/pdf/10.1126/science.abj8222?src=... [PDF]
stefantalpalaru
[dead]
account-5
Can I just take a minute to reflect on the start of the title of this article: Using lab-grown human mini-brains...
...
WTF is this!?
tremon
It's our first attempt at a cyborg, obviously: growing a human brain on a mycelium substrate connecting to robotic limbs.
ausbah
if i’m young, is there anything i can do to remove latent hsv1 viruses?
yakshaving_jgt
No, not yet. Your best hope is Dr Keith Jerome’s work.
Earw0rm
Makes me wonder if this or other viruses might have a role in the inflammation cascades that sometimes kill people after relatively minor head trauma.
I mean there are literally cases like Gabrielle Giffords where people have a penetrating bullet injury and live (not without damage, but they live), and others where a seemingly minor bump spirals to become fatal damage over the space of a few days to a week.
Oh yeah for sure. Other herpes link: It can be even worse if you somehow get it in your nose, where it could be a causal factor in "learning and behavioral deficiencies and violence in children and adults", as well as other risks from other forms of herpes like HHV-6 via that route, nice and close to the brain, and also possibly linked to the development of multiple sclerosis. [1][2] It's worth noting to those that don't know that this virus lies dormant in your spinal cord and can eventually travel to the brain, causing encephalitis and as the research has actually been saying for some time now is probably also linked to alzheimers, and there's also an increased incidence of alzheimers between spouses [3]. Lots of indications that we should probably figure out a way to stamp these viruses out if we're to totally be past these extremely debilitating and life ending conditions as a species.
[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8560783/
[2] https://www.livescience.com/15453-nose-gateway-virus-brain-d...
[3] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2945313/